atlas2




  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    Virgin Mary should not be depicted in pain while labouring



    Molanus argues that a recurrent depiction of the Virgin Mary during labour is incorrect and deviates from the Holy Scriptures and the teachings of the Church.

    Conflict
    Not corresponding to Scriptures
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Birth of Christ ; Midwives ; Virgin Mary
  • The Lord at the supper at the house of Martha and Mary



    Molanus condemns the depiction of Christ in blasphemous and funny manners in artworks about Christ in the house of Martha and Mary.

    Conflict
    Derision/Blasphemy Indecency/Impropriety
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Christ in the house of Martha and Mary
  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    Cupid is a poetic fiction



    Molanus condemns images of Cupid because the ordinary people do not understand his poetic meaning and therefore he only has negative effects on them.

    Conflict
    Figurative vs. literal reading Sacred vs. profane imagery
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Cupid
  • How to represent St. Catherine of Siena (and how not to do it)



    Dealing with the story of St. Catherine of Siena and how to represent it, Pacheco indicates three things to be analysed: that the saint had no external wounds, but they should be painted, and the way to paint them correctly.

    Conflict
    Impropriety Not corresponding with visual tradition Untruthfulness/Not probable/Not corresponding to history
    Mention
    Seville, 1649
    Subject
    St. Catherine of Siena
  • Joseph depicted as an old man



    Molanus affirms that the depiction of Joseph as an old man comes from apocryphal sources, but if done in a benevolent way, it does not constitute an error.

    Conflict
    Acceptable errors Not corresponding to Scriptures Not corresponding with Church teaching/dogma
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Joseph
  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    Limbs made of precious materials to commemorate the dead



    Molanus discusses objects between the categories of sacred and profane art and gives the example of limbs out of precious materials that decorate churches to commemorate the dead.

    Conflict
    Sacred vs. profane imagery
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Death
  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    The creation of artworks based on distorted memories



    Molanus condemns images cults dedicated to worldly rulers.

    Conflict
    Iconoclasm/Critic to image cult
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Image cult of worldly rulers
  • The Virgin del Pilar is like a sailing ship

    Zaragoza


    Conflict
    Morisco
    Mention
    Aragon, 1578
    Subject
    Virgin of Pilar
  • The correct way of depicting the “Baptism of Christ”



    Pacheco states in this passage how should be depicted the scene of “Baptism of Christ”. Also, he mentions the image made by Jeronimo Nadal as a good model to be followed, although the author comments on the necessity to be added a few more elements to the scene.

    Conflict
    Mention
    Seville, 1649
    Subject
    Baptism of Christ
  • Christ depicted as the Salvator Mundi



    Molanus assesses iconographic traditions which are based on well-established stories, here: Christ depicted as the Salvator Mundi.

    Conflict
    Visual tradition/Artistic model vs. written Tradition/History
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Jesus Christ ; Salvator Mundi
  • Attributes in recent paintings of historical figures, such as Jerome, do not mean that they really had them



    Molanus argues that in the depiction of holy figures their exterior features, such as their clothes or the attributes they hold, do not mean the historical figure him- or herself possessed or used these.

    Conflict
    Clothes anachronism/Errors/Adornment Figurative vs. literal reading
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Jerome
  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    All impudence in images should be avoided



    Molanus argues that saints should not be adorned with profane or ungodly elements, nor should they have the faces of people who are still alive.

    Conflict
    Clothes anachronism/Errors/Adornment Outer appearance
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Saints
  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    On how to depict St. Andrew



    Molanus discusses the exterior features of St. Andrew would have been black of medium height and with a full beard.

    Conflict
    Outer appearance Visual tradition/Artistic model vs. written Tradition/History
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    St. Andrew
  • Series of twelve images with the Passion of Christ, which are considered suspect of Lutheranism

    Valencia


    Letter of the Suprema to the Inquisitiors of the town of Valencia describing some cavases that allegedly entered the kingdom and recommending that they be collected so that they do not continue to circulate.

    Conflict
    Lutheran
    Mention
    Valencia, 3. October 1571
    Subject
    Passion of Christ
  • Arguing over a painting

    Palermo


    Alfonso Ortiz, a Neapolitan, argued with the painter from whom he had commissioned the canvas, threw it to the ground and broke the loom.

    Conflict
    Destruction
    Mention
    Palermo, 1580
    Subject
    St. Jerome
  • Frontispiece of: Gilio, Giovanni Andrea, Due dialogi (1564), Camerino : Antonio Giojoso

    The artists’ abuse of the age



    In this section of the dialogue, the participants address various cases of abuse in the representation of saints. The central focus is on the incorrect representation of age.

    Conflict
    Beard Capriccio Clothes anachronism/Errors/Adornment Ignorance/Negligence of the artist Not corresponding to Scriptures Untruthfulness/Not probable/Not corresponding to history
    Mention
    Fabriano, 1564
    Subject
    Inaccuracy of the artists ; Mary Magdalene ; Mary of Alpheus ; Mary of Cleophas ; Other Marys ; Posture of the figures ; St. Benedict ; St. Bernard ; St. Dominic ; St. Francis ; St. Jerome ; St. John the Baptist ; St. John the Evangelist ; St. Joseph ; St. Peter ; St. Romauld
  • The dishonourable way of painting angels as figures and faces of women



    Pacheco criticises how often painters used to make their angelic figures and faces like those of women: according to the author, elements such as heads adorned with curls and “feminine tresses in their hair, and “enlarged breasts” are unworthy and do not correspond to the best way of representing the “perfection” of angels.

    Conflict
    Clothes Nudity/Obscenity/Lasciviousness
    Mention
    Seville, 1649
    Subject
    Angels
  • How to represent St. Peter (and how not to do it)



    Dealing with the story of St. Peter (Apostle), Pacheco analyses the correct way of representing the saint, not just presenting a few models to follow, but also some inadequate manners of depicting specific scenes/elements of the saint’s life, such as depicting St. Peter bald or tied to the cross with cords.

    Conflict
    Clothes Not corresponding with visual tradition Untruthfulness/Not probable/Not corresponding to history
    Mention
    Seville, 1649
    Subject
    St. Peter (Apostle)
  • The Virgin Mary kneeling during the Nativity of Christ



    Molanus argues that depicting the Virgin Mary kneeling in front of the infant Christ are allowed.

    Conflict
    Not corresponding with Church teaching/dogma
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Nativity of Christ
  • Frostispiece of Molanus, De historia sanctarum imaginum et picturarum (1617), Antwerp, Gasparus Bellerus

    Paintings ridiculing the Holy Scriptures are blasphemous



    Molanus condemns ridiculing holy stories and persons as an act of blasphemy and those who practice such matters should be punished for it.

    Conflict
    Derision/Blasphemy Indecency/Impropriety
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Ridiculing of Holy stories and persons
  • Moral significance of insects



    Molanus discusses the usefulness of insects, spiders, ants and similar animals in painting and indicates their moral significance and therefore usefulness to painting.

    Conflict
    Sacred vs. profane imagery
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Ants ; Insects ; Spiders
  • Idols and images are not to be adored

    Aragon


    Bernat de Angay, a French-born prisoner claims to have read in the Apocalypse that the images should not be venerated

    Conflict
    Iconoclasm/Critic to image cult
    Mention
    Aragon, 1586
    Subject
    Idols
  • A heretical way of representing the “Annunciation”



    According to Pacheco, from an analysis made by Molanus, an erroneous, dangerous, and heretical manner of representing the Annunciation is, instead of depicting the Holy Spirit, adding a glow on the head of the Virgin, and in it a naked Child Jesus, with a cross on his shoulder, and the angels with God, the Father.

    Conflict
    Heretical image Impropriety Inadequate manner
    Mention
    Seville, 1649
    Subject
    The Annunciation
  • How to represent Christ in the cross

    Madrid, El Escorial Church, altar of the San Lorenzo el Real choir stalls;

    ,

    1556


    Francisco Pacheco in this passage created a response to Francisco de Rioja with the intention of counter-arguing him on his theory that Christ would be crucified with three nails, instead of four. Also, the author states that Christ should be not naked, but rather wear a white cloth and use the crown of thorns on the Cross.

    Conflict
    Impropriety Inadequate manner
    Mention
    Seville, 1649
    Subject
    Crucifixion ; Passion of Christ
  • Iconographies refuted by the commentators but popular with the people (Seven Falls of Christ; Mary pierced by Seven Swords; Mary’s three Vows)



    Molanus argues that as long as paintings that promote stories or subjects that do not derive from the Scriptures and that neither have been approved by the commentators do not lead to impiety they are allowed.

    Conflict
    Acceptable errors Not corresponding to Scriptures Not corresponding with Church teaching/dogma
    Mention
    Leuven, 1617
    Subject
    Mary pierced by seven swords ; Mary's three vows ; Seven falls of Christ